Rental player or not, Holliday could be on the move. And if Billy Beane doesn't ask the farm for Holliday I think Uncle Walt needs to make this move. This could have the same impact that Mark McGwire did for the Cardinals when Walt acquired him from Oakland. Plus, Holliday in the Reds lineup can take some pressure off of Jay Bruce and replace the lost production with Joey Votto on the DL. And if Great American Ballpark isn't the best thing to hit in next to Coors Field, I don't know what ballpark is.
This deal makes all the sense in the world.