Over the 3 drafts of Buckley's tenure (not including 2009 because it's obviously way too early), let's compare the Reds and the Giants top picks in each draft (and this is not just about Stubbs/Lincecum):
Compare that to:
Which would you rather have?
That's not the only example:
The Rays have produced Evan Longoria, David Price, and Tim Beckham over that time.
The Dodgers: Clayton Kershaw, Ethan Martin, Chris Withrow and Dee Gordon.
The Orioles: Brian Matusz, Matt Weiters, Jake Arrieta and Bill Rowell.
The Tigers: Rick Porcello, Andrew Miller, Casey Crosby, Ryan Perry, and Cody Satterwhite.
The Mariners: Brandon Morrow, Chris Tillman, Phillipe Aumont, and Josh Fields.
The list goes on and on...