Quote Originally Posted by traderumor View Post
But aren't post mortem's on signings important to learning? Maybe this discussion isn't so much about "I told you so" as it is "what can we learn from this flop." At least that's what I see. Some want to make it into that old RZ favorite, which has even been debated, in "I called it" and "no you didn't," "yes I did," "no you didn't." Fun.
I thought this was discussion about the rationale for the signing. How can the rationale be discussed without reasonably addressing potential outcomes? This is especially so when the results of this one were so wacky that simply using the results doesn't inform a whole lot concerning the rationale.