Aroldis Chapman Trade Advice

[HayPay]

I play in a 12 team Head to Head points league. I was offered a trade that has been baffling me for hours! Lets cut to the chase.


Team 1 gets Aroldis Chapman, Aaron Hill, David Wright


Team 2 gets Ricky Nolasco, Jay Bruce, Chase Utley


This is a keeper league if that matters.

Thanks for your time and advice.
John m

[Tornon]

I like Team 2's side.. mostly because Utley is a stud, I think Hill will fall back to earth to some degree, and I don't know if Wright's 2009 is a sign of things to come. Bruce is probably going to improve, and Nolasco has put together pretty good back to back seasons. And I still don't know what to think about Chapman when dealing with fantasy stuff yet.. others probably value him alot more than I do.

[HayPay]

Thanks Toron for your opinion. Im really stuck on this.

[AtomicDumpling]

I think group #2 has a slight edge over group #1, but that seems to be a very equal trade in my opinion.

[Eric_the_Red]

Team #2 and it isn't close.

[REDblooded]

Team 2 for me too... Is it a keeper or dynasty though?