Yes, a knee jerk reaction to Friday's game, but something that I've been wondering about for awhile.
Both are young, flyball pitchers who have yet to really find it. I think unless they close the gap in GABP to get rid of the wind tunnel in right center, there is no way the Reds can afford to keep both and compete.
If the Reds played in a less homer friendly park, they could let both of them work things out in the hope that at least one of them reaches their potential. But in GABP, when they make just one mistake, they get hammered. I don't see this letting up.
I say trade at least on of them for a real LF. One of them and Phillips would get a great one.