I was looking at the Brewers batting averages this year against Garcia.

Weeks, Hart, and Fielder are all batting over .300 against him with like 8 or 9 at-bats each.

Braun has 2 hits in 8 at-bats.

Dave Bush goes for the Brewers.
Pujols is 6-20 against him with no HR's.
Molina is 5-19 with 3 HR's. Not kidding.
Holliday is 6-14 with 1 HR.

Looks like a win for the Cards on paper.