Fangraphs just rolled out a splits feature on their leaderboards.
In "High Leverage" situations, Joey Votto had the 2nd best wOBA (.542) in baseball -- 152 qualified players. Nelson Cruz was #1.
#152? Rajai Davis. #151? That would be Derek Jeter. ARod was 8th.
If "clutch" exists as a repeatable skill and not just a descriptor of circumstance, it sure as heck manifests itself in weird ways...