40 years ago (1971), a 3-2 11-inning loss at Shea Stadium in Queens.
Cincinnati
Pete Rose rf
Tommy Helms 2b
Tony Perez 1b
Johnny Bench c
Hal McRae cf
Bernie Carbo lf
Bill Plummer 3b
Frank Duffy ss
Gary Nolan p
New York Mets
Tommie Agee cf
Bud Harrelson ss
Cleon Jones lf
Art Shamsky rf
Donn Clendenon 1b
Ken Boswell 2b
Bob Aspromonte 3b
Jerry Grote c
Jerry Koosman p
WP: Danny Frisella (1-0)
LP: Wayne Granger (0-2)
HR: CIN - Bernie Carbo (1).