The most amazing play I've seen in person was Ryan Freel's diving catch of an Albert Pujols bomb late in the 2006 season. Does anyone remember this catch? The Reds faded that season and the Cards won the division and later the World Series, but that catch at the base of the warning track was one of the more remarkable plays I've EVER seen. It happened right in front of me, and I still have no idea whatsoever how he got to that ball.