The discussion in the second thread wasn't as lively as the first so I figured I'd ask before I go to all the work of doing writeups: one for the rotation, then one last one for the bullpen and bench.
I've enjoyed having discussions with you guys and have been really, really pleased at the class everyone has shown with being able to debate baseball and not resort to any trolling or name calling. There hasn't been even one bad apple and I think that says a lot about this message board and Reds fans in general.