Louisville?
It really is tough, because neither of them are top of the order guys.
I think Phillips/ Stubbs/ Votto/ Beethoven/ Bruce/ Rolen/ Cozy/ Hanny makes the most sense for the playoffs....with Cozy and Stubby being candidates to be PH for in late innings by Frazier or Rolen the first time a RISP comes up from the 7th on.