I know it wasn't made clear in this thread, but in the first version of this thread the OP asked us to vote for who SHOULD BE on the roster, not who WILL BE on the roster. Instead of trying to predict what Dusty will do, vote based on what YOU would do.
I think it is pretty easy to predict what Dusty will do. It is a lot more interesting to hear what Redszoners would do.
By the way, I agree with you. Dusty will pick Valdez but I would pick Gregorius.