Who is Redszone's #3 prospect? 2013

[Kc61]

In this case and similar cases, you could just ask the (very few) people who didn't vote for Cingrani or Corcino to re-vote for one of them. There's your re-vote.

Could be fast and easy, if it could be done.

[Steve4192]

No need for a runoff.

It's a stone cold lock that Cingrani-Corcino will be #3 and #4. It doesn't really matter who ends up where. Honestly, given how close the vote is, you should probably just declare it a tie and skip to the #5 spot.

[Nathan]

This will be one of those debates that we will be interesting to look at 3-4 years from now and see how it turns out.

[RED VAN HOT]

I also went with Winker even though the obvious choices were the C and C pitchers. His OPS and plate discipline as an 18 yo playing against mostly college pitchers or more experienced young players suggest that he has a chance to be a good hitter capable of moving through the minors more quickly. Looks like a strong corner OF'er of the future to me.

[REDblooded]

Early in the voting I'll take ceiling over floor, hence my pick for Corcino

[Kc61]

Early in the voting I'll take ceiling over floor, hence my pick for Corcino

I don't get this.

Corcino does not have projectable size for a starting pitcher. His K rate last year at AA was 7.9 per nine innings. His career K rate is 8.7 per nine.

Cingrani is 6'4" and 200. His K rate at AA was 10.2. His minor league career K rate is 11.5.

Corcino may be more likely to be a solid pro. But Cingrani seems to have a higher ceiling IMO. Cingrani has more of an MLB pitcher's build and misses more bats.