yes, this is just an effort to please the detractors of the Dunn, EE, and Hamilton departures. I forgot Hamilton and don't know where he plays with Choo, so bye bye Choo:
Phillips 2b
Dunn 1b
Votto LF (kept there in 2006 when AD was moved to 1b)
EE 3b
Hamilton CF
Mez C
Bruce RF
Cozart SS