Final spot of RedsZone's postseason roster

[chicoruiz]

Nobody's really enthusiastic about Valdez, but a vote is a vote. So now we come down to the really interesting one.

[REDREAD]

So the Redszone roster is now at 24:

Pitchers (11)- Cueto, Latos, Arroyo, Bailey, Chapman, Marshall, Broxton, Hoover, LeCure, Leake, Arredondo

Catchers (2)- Hanigan, Navarro

Infielders (5)- Votto, Phillips, Rolen, Cozart, Frazier, Valdez.

Outfielders (5)- Ludwick, Stubbs, Bruce, Heisey, Paul

I'm struggling between Cairo and Mez.. Both are impotent bats.
Cairo gives you some insurance against Rolen's back.
Mez lets you use Navarro as a PH.

I don't want 12 pitchers in the postseason..

[bucksfan2]

Best bat available at this point. Don't know if that is Mesoraco or HRod.

[Edd Roush]

Originally Posted by bucksfan2

Best bat available at this point. Don't know if that is Mesoraco or HRod.

Thats my thought process too and I think HRod is the best bat, so I voted for him.

[Kc61]

Mes - he allows the team to use Navarro as a pinch hitter.

[crazybob60]

I am going with the same vote as previous -- Alfredo Simon

[mth123]

I want the 12th pitcher. I don't want the team to hesitate to pull a guy before its too late. I think the Rangers and the Cards both blazed a trail last season where the starter comes out early and there are lots of guys showing different looks to keep hitters off balance. IMO, the best way to do that is with the 3rd lefty for the pen, so I vote Cingrani. I don't see a position player available that is going to add much, may as well add the utility to the staff.

[George Foster]

I hate to say it but Dusty needs to follow the Tony La Russa fomula. If there is a situation in the 5,6, inning and you have a chance to score runs, you pinch hit for your starter, trust your bull pen. Runs are at a premium. With a runner on 2nd, and 3rd with 1 or 2 outs you let Paul have a chance. I think we need the extra arm in the bullpen.

[757690]

Originally Posted by mth123

I want the 12th pitcher. I don't want the team to hesitate to pull a guy before its too late. I think the Rangers and the Cards both blazed a trail last season where the starter comes out early and there are lots of guys showing different looks to keep hitters off balance. IMO, the best way to do that is with the 3rd lefty for the pen, so I vote Cingrani. I don't see a position player available that is going to add much, may as well add the utility to the staff.

The Cards and Rangers starters were being pulled early all season long, because they weren't very good.

Reds with this roster have Lecure, and Leake who could go long. No need for an extra pitcher.

I voted for Cairo, because I can see him going all Kurt Bevacqua in the post season

[mth123]

Originally Posted by 757690

The Cards and Rangers starters were being pulled early all season long, because they weren't very good.

Reds with this roster have Lecure, and Leake who could go long. No need for an extra pitcher.

I voted for Cairo, because I can see him going all Kurt Bevacqua in the post season

They weren't routinely taking guys out in the 4th or 5th by design until the post season.

Bevacqua hasn't gotten a hit in 27 years. I could see Cairo doing that.

Honsetly, there isn't a position player on that list that will add anything that they can't gut from Leake or Arroyo. I'd rather have the extra lefty, but I'm pretty sure that you are right and Cairo will be on the roster.

[klw]

Originally Posted by 757690

I voted for Cairo, because I can see him going all Kurt Bevacqua in the post season

He will blow big bubbles on the bench. This is all I have ever thought of when I think of Bevacqua as I started collecting cards in '76.

[klw]

I was torn with this one. I think having having another lefty in the pen and a long arm at that would be great. I think cairo is one of those guys who we would all scream if he was used until he got the big clutch hit. Gregorious has impressed and would give a nice set of extra wheels and a glove. I went with Simon. He has been very underrated and can go long if needed though if Leake is on the squad having a lefty in Cingrani might be preferred. Oh well. Glad this decision isn't mine.

[cincinnati chili]

I voted for Mesoroco because I'd prefer to have a 3rd catcher. But I'm not sure of the current rules on injuries to catchers in the first round. I think that MLB was toying with the idea of letting you activate/deactivate a player mid-series in the first round in the case of an injury, in which case I'd prefer someone other than a third catcher.

Are we all aware that Logan Ondrusek has stranded 42 of 46 runners this year and 103 out of 124 in his career?

[REDREAD]

Originally Posted by cincinnati chili

Are we all aware that Logan Ondrusek has stranded 42 of 46 runners this year and 103 out of 124 in his career?

I agree that Logan isn't as bad as he's percieved on this board.
I don't want to look up the numbers right now, but my perception is he is pretty solid for long periods of times, then seems to go through a struggling period.

I think LeCure and Leake can cover the long/middle innings. Cingrani.. he just doesn't seem quite ready for prime time yet.. No point in adding him on the postseason roster if Dusty doesn't have 100% confidence in him.

I guess I feel that if we have to pull a starter in the 3rd inning twice in a playoff series, we're probably toast anyhow, so I want 11 pitchers. (Also, there's plenty of off days in the postseason to rest the staff). In all honesty, the odds of Leake pitching in a playoff game on this Redszone roster are pretty slim.

[Rojo]

Originally Posted by REDREAD

I guess I feel that if we have to pull a starter in the 3rd inning twice in a playoff series, we're probably toast anyhow, so I want 11 pitchers. (Also, there's plenty of off days in the postseason to rest the staff). In all honesty, the odds of Leake pitching in a playoff game on this Redszone roster are pretty slim.

Yes. I dont' see the need for another short guy in the pen. Chapman, Marshall, Broxton, Hoover, LeCure and Arrendondo should have innnings 6-9 covered. The only contingency is a guy getting knocked out early or extras. That's why you have Leake.

I want another bat. I went with Cairo -- he's due.

If Heisey starts, that leaves Paul as your first lefty off the bench and Stubbs as your first righty. As a plus hitter vs. lefties and a guy who can turn a single into a triple, Stubbs actually becomes a pretty nice weapon in a short series.