Who is Redszone's #21 prospect for 2013?

[texasdave]

1) Billy Hamilton
2) Robert Stephenson
3) Tony Cingrani
4) Daniel Corcino
5) Jesse Winker
6) Nick Travieso
7) Henry Rodriguez
8) Ismael Guillon
9) Yorman Rodriguez
10) Tanner Rahier
11) Dan Langfield
12) Neftali Soto
13) Donald Lutz
14) Chad Rogers
15) Tucker Barnhart
16) David Vidal
17) Seth Mejias-Brean
18) Kyle Lotzkar
19) Jeff Gelalich
20) Ryan LaMarre

[texasdave]

If anyone wants a player added just let me know.

I am still going with the next Mike Leake. Drew Cisco.

[dougdirt]

Went with Ryan Wright here. He has a solid all around toolset. None that are really above-average, but none that are really below-average either. He has put up solid numbers as well. I could probably vote for 10-20 guys here and make sense of it though.

[mace]

Originally Posted by texasdave

If anyone wants a player added just let me know.

I am still going with the next Mike Leake. Drew Cisco.

I feel that Drew Hayes should be on the list, but no rush. I'm not ready to vote for him. I just think he's at roughly the level of the list, as it stands. Like Doug said, most of these guys are tenable picks right now.

Especially Waldrop. (I like Cisco, too.)

[Red Swagger]

Ryan Wright, again.. Drew Cisco is going to have a monster year in 2013

[marcshoe]

I went with Reynoso based on tools. Honestly, I have no confidence in him, but at this point, there are no guarantees.

[AtomicDumpling]

I voted for Garrett again. Both he and Reynoso should have been voted in about 6 places ago.

[The DARK]

I'm not exactly blown away by Kyle Waldrop... he's got some tools, but I just can't get excited for him at this rank. I'll pick Reynoso, as I've gone for about the last 8-10 picks.

[REDblooded]

BA and Keith Law both had Reynoso ranked inside the top 10 in the Reds organization... Here we are at 21 and he's still on the fence. What's the rub?

[REDblooded]

BA and Keith Law both had Reynoso ranked inside the top 10 in the Reds organization... Here we are at 20 and he's still on the fence. What's the rub?

[OGB]

Garrett
Guy has the body and arm to be a #1. He has a really long way to go, but as far as I'm concerned most of the players left are either likely non starters at the pro level or prospects with a whole lot to prove. I think Garrett is a prospect with a lot to prove with the highest ceiling of everyone left.

[Edd Roush]

I like Amir Garrett as a prospect, but he is not even fully committed to baseball yet.

The vote has to go to Reynoso here. I trust those who get paid to do it, and it's easy to vote for a guy with a great hit tool and who has potential with the other tools.

Waldrop is an interesting prospect, but his ceiling isnt as high as Reynosos. You gotta trust the experts and go with the guy who hit 300+ his first year in the States.

[dougdirt]

Originally Posted by REDblooded

BA and Keith Law both had Reynoso ranked inside the top 10 in the Reds organization... Here we are at 20 and he's still on the fence. What's the rub?

Well, to be honest, anyone after that top 6, the next 15-20 can all probably be argued to be in the top 10.

Personally, with Reynoso, I have him a little further down the list because he is still a very raw baseball player. He can run and he can make contact. He isn't a good defender (though he has the tools to be an excellent one). He is very aggressive at the plate. He doesn't run the bases well, despite the 30 steals. There is a lot of baseball that he needs to learn still.

[OGB]

Originally Posted by Edd Roush

I like Amir Garrett as a prospect, but he is not even fully committed to baseball yet.

Having seen St Johns play several times this year, including the game that just ended, I get the feeling that if Garrett has any success this year baseball-wise, he'll pack the sneakers up. He does get a fair amount of minutes, but it's pretty clear he would have to make enormous improvements to his game to be considered a draftable prospect--the kind of improvement you don't often see from a college bball player from his soph year on.

[mace]

Somebody needs to vote, quick, and break this deadlock. We don't have time for another tirebreaker.