Help me with this trade

[Redsman88]

I liked ur guys advice on the wilkerson/patterson comparison so im coming back for more. I play in an auction keeper league just to refresh ur memories. Heres me team



C Estrada
1b Huff
2b B.Boone
3b D.Young
ss K.Matsui
of B.Bonds
of M.Lawton
of P.Wilson
of J.Guillen
utl. J.Damon
Bn J.Dye
Bn B.Wilkerson
Dl. A.Kearns

SP M Prior
SP C. Carpenter
RP D. Graves
RP J. Nathan
P D. Kolb
P J. Julio
P B. Zito
Bn. A. Burnett
Bn. B. Penny
Bn. J Beckett

Ive been offered C.Jones and R. Halladay for J. Guillen and B. Penny
I know this helps my pitching, but do you guys think it takes away too much hitting? Thanx for the help.

[Ender]

I don't think it does. Guillen seems pretty streaky to me, and I think Chipper has to rebound to his usual .300 self after the break. Plus you can play Chipper at 3rd if needed. I'd take it and run, but that's just me. :

I would try to give him Guillen and Carpenter because I dont think Carpenter can keep it up for the whole year

[Red Leader]

I think the hitters are pretty even, and I think you're getting the better deal in SP. I like Carpenter's chances of success more than Penny's. Carpenter will get plenty of support in the second half and his team is ROLLING right now. I think Chipper will be good in the second half with Giles back in front of him and Andruw and J.D. around him. I'd do it.