If you had the power and the opportunity, would you trade Cincy's starting rotation, as is, for Chicagos, as is?
The deal would be:
CIN:
Harang
Arroyo
Cueto
Volquez
Fogg
for
CHI:
Zambrano
Hill
Lilly
Dempster
Marquis
I have a feeling that most non-Reds fans or people with no affiliation to either team would take Chicago's but, I think I'd stick with ours.