Tucker Barnhart went 5-5 with a home run and a double for the Blaze, who won 12-2.
Tucker Barnhart went 5-5 with a home run and a double for the Blaze, who won 12-2.
I am surprised Billy Hamilton has not yet been promoted. Maybe the Reds brass know something I don't.
Get MLBtraderumors Reds updates on Facebook.
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Reds-R...33794710005587
http://i.imgur.com/1bCKpaH.jpg
Well, what is it that you know?
Hamilton has things he can work on in Bakersfield. There is another very good shortstop in AA and the guy playing shortstop in AAA is also playing very well and also a very good defender. You can't promote a guy up a level unless you have a plan for the guy at his position ahead of him.
Right now, Billy Hamilton is a slap hitter who strikes out 17% of the time he steps to the plate. That isn't good. He has a .116 Isolated power.
Here are the OPS numbers for guys in the Major Leagues with a 16-18% strikeout rate (that is 1% in each direction of Hamilton) and a sub .130 ISoP since the start of 2011 with at least 300 PA's:
.728
.721
.719
.706
.692
.692
.688
.663
.639
.633
.630
.603
.599
.591
.543
.528
.508
.482
The game that Billy Hamilton currently has is not one that is going to translate to the Major Leagues. He has plenty of work to do.
Billy Hamilton's last two halves of baseball as a professional:
Dayton (A-) .333/ .396/ .410/ .806
Bakersfield (A+) .331/ .416/ .447/ .864
Overall, in around 600 ABs:
.332/ .408/ .430/ 838 130 SB/ 29 CS
While I agree that he has plenty to work on, let's not lose sight of the forest for the trees. Hamilton is, by all accounts aside from yours, a supremely gifted athlete who focused on baseball only two years ago. He learned how to switch hit as a professional (something that's incredibly rare). He makes plays literally no one else makes at his position. His slugging percentage is obviously speed-driven, but a .450 slugging isn't bad, especially from a guy that's at the top of the order, takes a walk, and steals as many bases as Hamilton does.
Last edited by Scrap Irony; 06-22-2012 at 02:06 PM.
I really think people need to pay more attention to what I say. No where have I said Hamilton is a fantastic athlete. What I said is that he isn't a super athlete on par with guys like Josh Hamilton.
BA/OBP/SLG in the minors doesn't just translate forward. It doesn't.
Let's take a quick math session here and just project Billy Hamilton based on what we know about him.....
Let's say he has a 9% walk rate and a 17% strikeout rate at the MLB level with 2 home runs that go over the fence. Let's toss in 12 triples and 30 doubles. Sound reasonable? We will also toss in 3 sac bunts, a sac fly and 5 HBP's.
Here is what his line would be given a BABIP between .314 and .347, something that isn't a given at all.
Even with a much higher than you should expect BABIP, Hamilton, with the power/walks/strikeouts supplied, is a .738 OPS bat.Code:PA AB H 2B 3B HR BB K HBP SH SF AVG OBP SLG OPS BABIP 650 583 150 30 12 2 58 111 5 3 1 .257 .329 .360 .689 .314 650 583 155 30 12 2 58 111 5 3 1 .266 .337 .369 .706 .325 650 583 160 30 12 2 58 111 5 3 1 .274 .345 .377 .722 .335 650 583 165 30 12 2 58 111 5 3 1 .283 .352 .386 .738 .346
Career BABIP for other known speedsters:
Michael Bourn: .345
Deion Sanders: .298
Rickey Henderson: .305
Bo Jackson: .320
Willy Taveras: .320
Juan Pierre: .314
Dee Gordon: .310
Vince Coleman: .314
What if Hamilton finds his way into most of that group and settles at .315-.320? Then we are looking at a guy who might OPS .680-.700.
Now, there can be plenty of value in that because if it is coming along with a .340 OBP, that works just fine when coupled with his stealing and defense. But my point is more that he has plenty to work on still offensively as well as defensively because his offensive game isn't something that is going to come forward and produce like it has in the minors this year at the MLB level without improvements somewhere in the peripherals (be it losing some strikeouts, adding some power, adding more walks.... something needs to change).
doug, he's lost strike outs for the past two years. The first half of last season, his K rate was ridiculous. Then, as he gained experience, it lessened greatly. This season, he's again improved his K rate.
He's looking an awful lot like Dexter Fowler, but with better speed. And, at this point, at SS. Fowler had a higher K rate, less power, and hit in the same league. Fowler improved his K rate; why wouldn't Hamilton?
Don't like Fowler? How about Rafael Furcal? Higher K rate again, less slugging. Fewer walks, too. He turned out pretty good, yes?
Brett Gardner is another one, doug. His K rate was (again) much higher than Hamilton's in A+, and his slugging about the same. He's turned into a pretty spectacular major league leadoff hitter.
And those are literally three of the first five guys I looked up. (The others being Jimmy Rollins and Shane Victorino.)
It's one thing to show numbers from the major leagues, but Hamilton is still learning his craft. And he's showing some monumental improvement AND producing at a phenomenal rate.
I get that you don't like him as a prospect nearly as much as... well, anyone else. I get that he needs to do some work. But, fact is, he's showing some pretty solid signs right now, regardless of current IsoSlg or K rate.
Last edited by Scrap Irony; 06-22-2012 at 05:51 PM.
I guess I already missed an argument on this. But I respect a lot of things you say, and this is one that I think you are way off on.I said is that he isn't a super athlete on par with guys like Josh Hamilton.
Unless you are saying he isn't up there because of his strength. But as far as athleticism goes, it's an 80 if you want to grade it. And he is a far better athlete than Josh Hamilton today.
I used to say the same thing about Drew Stubbs' minor-league numbers, but you and others would argue with me.
Hamilton will be fine. If Stubbs can carve out a Big League career based totally on speed (OK and some occasional power) than the even-faster Hamilton will too. The question is how good of a MLB player he will be. Not sure about that, but I have no doubt he'll be in The Show for years. And at least he knows he's a "slap hitter" ... we don't have to worry about him thinking he's some power hitter.
Board Moderators may, at their discretion and judgment, delete and/or edit any messages that violate any of the following guidelines: 1. Explicit references to alleged illegal or unlawful acts. 2. Graphic sexual descriptions. 3. Racial or ethnic slurs. 4. Use of edgy language (including masked profanity). 5. Direct personal attacks, flames, fights, trolling, baiting, name-calling, general nuisance, excessive player criticism or anything along those lines. 6. Posting spam. 7. Each person may have only one user account. It is fine to be critical here - that's what this board is for. But let's not beat a subject or a player to death, please. |