Would Pete Rose...

[redsupport]

He would be reviled because he did not handle the career of Kalvoski Daniels optimally.

[Handofdeath]

Originally Posted by Ltlabner

...be as revered if he had played for the Dodgers in the 70's?

Would his brand of "give it your all" baseball still be respected by the fans in Cincy who generally admire and respond to hard-charging baseball players?

Or would he be dispised because he was a Dodger thus the exact same Pete Rose would be loathed instead of deified.

I think he would be respected, to a point. But Cincy fans always love their own (The Reds) more. One of the greatest catches I ever saw was David Wright's dive into the stands to catch that foul ball. I mentioned it to a good friend (TRF actually) and he immediately named off several by Ryan Freel that he thought were better and he didn't think half a second about it. I admire that kind of loyalty. He was wrong but I admire that.

[StillFunkyB]

Originally Posted by Team Clark

I agree with that 100%. I do have a question for you. Do you remember Dykstra for being a met or a Philly? I remember him more as a Philly.

Philly, but the baseball card I had of him was as a Met. Drove past one of his carwashes when I was in SoCal a couple summers ago.

[writerdan33]

If Rose were still born and raised in Cincinnati, and the Reds passed on him, the answer to the question is no. He wouldn't have been as beloved as a Dodger because he never would have been a Dodger.

The only reason he was drafted by the Reds was as a favor to a family member who was a scout. Otherwise, he likely doesn't get a sniff of the Major Leagues.

Right man. Right place. Right circumstances. Right time.

The story simply doesn't work anywhere else.

[Team Clark]

Originally Posted by writerdan33

Right man. Right place. Right circumstances. Right time. The story simply doesn't work anywhere else.

Unfortuantely there was a "sad ending to a sorry episode" to make us look at the story in a different light.

[writerdan33]

Originally Posted by Team Clark

Unfortuantely there was a "sad ending to a sorry episode" to make us look at the story in a different light.

True, but I was only answering the originial question - Would Pete have been as revered if he were a Dodger?

It seems the thread got off track a bit from the original intent.

[Team Clark]

Originally Posted by writerdan33

True, but I was only answering the originial question - Would Pete have been as revered if he were a Dodger?

It seems the thread got off track a bit from the original intent.

Yeah, you're right about that and I agree with what you are saying. I think most kids growing up would want a scenario similar to Pete's. Playing in front of your family and friends. Wearing the uniform of the team you grew up idolizing. Ohh yeah and being a really good player on tp of that.