Refreshing Honesty

[runfreelrun]

I just have to say that I really enjoy the honesty in broadcasting from Brennaman and Brantley. Nothing against Grand and Welsh but I find it enjoyable that these guys say what all of us (well some of us) have been thinking for years. They called out Griffey today and Brantley wouldnt let it die, but he was right. They called out Valentine for swinging at 2 bad pitches after Aquino had thrown ten straight balls. While watching the game with my father today, I remarked that these guys must not have seen much Reds baseball the last couple of years, because they are amazed at things that have been going on for years, and Brennaman remarking "I am going to get off my high horse, as I was all over them in Arizona", as he was speaking about the Reds swinging at bad pitches in a hitters count. Brantley then remarked "I dont think the Reds have a take sign". Not that I like to see the Reds make mistakes or play bad ball, just like the announcers being honest and observant.

[WVPacman]

I like all four of our announcers,they all really tell it like it is. Brennaman and Brantley really tell the truth and I love it.Thats the main reason I like Marty b/c he tells the facts and thats what I want to hear when watching or listening to a game.

[TeamBoone]

Originally Posted by WVPacman

I like all four of our announcers,they all really tell it like it is. Brennaman and Brantley really tell the truth and I love it.Thats the main reason I like Marty b/c he tells the facts and thats what I want to hear when watching or listening to a game.

Marty often confuses fact with fiction (opinion).

[WVPacman]

Originally Posted by TeamBoone

Marty often confuses fact with fiction (opinion).

love him or hate him he always tells it like it is.

[TeamBoone]

Originally Posted by WVPacman

love him or hate him he always tells it like it is.

No. He doesn't. But you can always count on him to tell it like he THINKS it is.

[flyer85]

Originally Posted by runfreelrun

They called out Valentine for swinging at 2 bad pitches after Aquino had thrown ten straight balls.

the 2-0 pitch was thigh high right down the middle, exactly the kind of pitch he should be swinging at (the 2-1 pitch they rightly called him on) but in those situations you are looking for a pitch to drive and score multiple runs. Why let the pitcher off the hook by taking a really good pitch to hit?

[gonelong]

Originally Posted by TeamBoone

No. He doesn't. But you can always count on him to tell it like he THINKS it is.

Quoted for truth. (It is hard for me to cut on a guy that speaks his mind.)

I have to admit that I have enjoyed the duo of Thom and Brantley these last few games. I also REALLY enjoyed having Joe back in the booth.

GL

/Yes I am complimenting Reds announcers. That is all.

[TOBTTReds]

Originally Posted by flyer85

the 2-0 pitch was thigh high right down the middle, exactly the kind of pitch he should be swinging at (the 2-1 pitch they rightly called him on) but in those situations you are looking for a pitch to drive and score multiple runs. Why let the pitcher off the hook by taking a really good pitch to hit?

I'm with you.

On topic of the main post, Thom beats things to death. But thankfully he knows that and didn't mention plate patience tonight.

Brantley is only refreshing for me basically because he can recognize pitches, especially changeups. I swear no non-player can recognize a change up and it drives me crazy when they sit there and talk about the slider when it is not.

[WVPacman]

I agree with you flyer on the first strike,he did'nt have to swing but any batter would have.Dad and I laughed are butts off when they both said that he should not have swung then he slamed the ball for a three run double.lol

[jimbo]

Originally Posted by TeamBoone

No. He doesn't. But you can always count on him to tell it like he THINKS it is.

Isn't that part of his job?

[Doro]

agreed.... Welsh and Grande are homers

[thatcoolguy_22]

Originally Posted by Doro

agreed.... Welsh and Grande are homers

aren't we all though...

[KronoRed]

Originally Posted by TeamBoone

No. He doesn't. But you can always count on him to tell it like he THINKS it is.

Amen TB

[membengal]

Props to Thom B. for showing some self-awareness. His acknowledgement that he DID beat it to death in Arizona gives me hope. That line most of us see, where he can impart a criticism without leaving the point lifeless and strewn all over our tv sets, was found last night. He and Brantly had a solid broadcast...

[Natty Redlocks]

When Thom gets too critical he comes across as Marty's little mini-me. I'm guessing someone told him to ease up.