Heisey for Marmol?

[OnBaseMachine]

Originally Posted by dougdirt

Anyone can create an account and write an article on BR. Anyone. No one gets paid to write there. Like I said, with all due respect to Illya, the writer, I seriously have my doubts that he of all people landed this scoop while no one else has touched it.

Thanks. I'll say it again - I'll believe it when I saw it. I'd say there's probably about a 1% chance this happens.

[kbrake]

Originally Posted by Degenerate39

Who comes the the other outfielder? I dont think any of us want to answer that

Chris Dickerson. I don't know how soon he will be back but I don't think GMJ would be up here right away.

[corkedbat]

Originally Posted by HeatherC1212

I am DEFINITELY not in favor of any move that allows a certain player in Louisville any chance on being brought up to the Reds this year. I hope I don't have to mention the name of said player here.

Seeing as you are the head of the GMJ fanclub on these boards Heather, you don't need to say a thing. <Ducks!>

[HeatherC1212]

Originally Posted by corkedbat

Seeing as you are the head of the GMJ fanclub on these boards Heather, you don't need to say a thing. <Ducks!>

*pelts you with so many tomatoes you'll be seeing red for the next two weeks* :

I am the official head of the JOEY VOTTO fan club and don't you forget it.

[reds44]

Originally Posted by HeatherC1212

No thanks to this one and I hope it's just a rumor.

WHAT?

Are you kidding me? If this is true, I'll be doing backflips.

I mean really, I don't think there's a chance in hell the Cubs will do this trade.

[corkedbat]

Originally Posted by HeatherC1212

*pelts you with so many tomatoes you'll be seeing red for the next two weeks* :

I am the official head of the JOEY VOTTO fan club and don't you forget it.

SALSA! Yum! Wouldn't have any Cilantro would ya?

[HeatherC1212]

Originally Posted by corkedbat

SALSA! Yum! Wouldn't have any Cilantro would ya?

I'm out of that but I can offer you some pepper and ginger if you can make something out of those two things, LOL

Back on topic now....I'm still on board with no thank you to this trade. :

[corkedbat]

Wonder if Price could help Marmol cut back on the BBs?. He's the kind of power arm I'd like to have, but not at the full-price mentioned.

[reds44]

Just saw it was on bleacher report. There's a 0% chance this is true.

[kbrake]

That sucks was really hoping for that.

[Ghosts of 1990]

OMG.... I'd go nuts.

Guy is a STUD (Marmol). Heisey is not gonna turn into much. He's Chris Denorfia with better size.

That said, I'll guarantee you it doesn't happen.

[Hap]

one time in 2002, bill cunningham said bartolo colon would be a Red by "the end of the day" according to his sources

[Big Klu]

Originally Posted by JayBruce32

OMG.... I'd go nuts.

Guy is a STUD (Marmol). Heisey is not gonna turn into much. He's Chris Denorfia with better size.

That said, I'll guarantee you it doesn't happen.

I think Heisey is more like Tracy Jones without the cocky attitude.

[Ghosts of 1990]

Bleacher Report is so, so bad.

I don't even read articles on BR. That's how false and Madden-ish all their fantasy trades are. I thought the report was from MLBTR, and got excited. No way this happens.

[TheNext44]

Originally Posted by Ron Madden

I agree, I'm afraid this move would backfire. I wouldn't do it.

I agree that Marmol is a risk, and like so many relievers, he could turn into a pumpkin in the blink of an eye, especially with his walk rate. But I don't see Heisey ever being much more than a nice fourth outfielder, so I wouldn't mind taking that risk.

But I am 100% behind your skepticism of trading for relievers. To quote a posters username: Caveat Emptor.