Originally Posted by jojo
I personally think Williams got a bigger shaft in '42 and maybe even a bigger shaft in '47 than Trout did this year. I'd have voted for Trout but there's more romance in giving it to Cabrera though. Strip all of the romance from baseball and its not as compelling.
That a very good summation. I get the three triple crown categories aren't the best measure of value...but then i think he won the Triple Crown for God's sake, why are we complaining so much?