1990 Nlcs

[MaineRed]

Remember the throw that nailed Bobby Bonilla @ third? Who threw the ball, Eric Davis or Paul O'Neil?

This isn't a trivia question. I saw it reported that it was Davis and I seem to remember it being Paul. Now I'm confused.

Anyone?

[bounty37h]

Hmm, ya got me, but I would have guessed Davis, from limited memory.

[George Anderson]

Remember the throw that nailed Bobby Bonilla @ third? Who threw the ball, Eric Davis or Paul O'Neil?

This isn't a trivia question. I saw it reported that it was Davis and I seem to remember it being Paul. Now I'm confused.

Anyone?

I remember O'Neil nailing a runner at third but I thought the runner was Van Slyke.

[MaineRed]

Aaaaarrrrrrgggggg!!!!

:)

[ThatsAStrike]

Paul O'Neill made the throw. Van Slyke was the runner. That was one awesome throw and a great tag by Sabo.

[RedlegNation]

Definitely O'Neill. I can still remember screaming (for joy) when they called him out.

[Peyton's Place]

Wasn't there also a play in the NLCS where ED came from LF to CF (backing up Hatcher) fielded the ball and spun to throw a strike to 3B to nail the runner (Bonillia possibly)?

I may be wrong but I was thinking both ED and O'Neill had spectacular throws to 3B.

[redhawkfish]

The throw to get Bonilla at third by Davis was spectacular. Rijo was getting drilled in that inning, and Davis bailed him out with some help from Bonilla!:D

Both O'neill and Davis had great throws in 1990 NLCS. O'Neill's was in game two at home, and Davis' throw was in game 4 in Pittsburgh.

[bounty37h]

Wasn't there also a play in the NLCS where ED came from LF to CF (backing up Hatcher) fielded the ball and spun to throw a strike to 3B to nail the runner (Bonillia possibly)?

I may be wrong but I was thinking both ED and O'Neill had spectacular throws to 3B.

I think thats the one I was thinking of above^

[Bobcat J]

Retrosheet says that it was Davis who threw out Bonilla.

[redsupport]

oneill

[MaineRed]

Here is why I asked:

http://www.nypost.com/seven/06012007/sports/lame_excuses_have_to_run_out_sports_phil_mushnick. htm


Since 1990, when the hideous, cool-over-function trend of jogging toward first or immodestly loitering near home plate in the often erroneous presumption the ball will land over the fence had fully set in, big-league games have been determined by inexcusably indifferent - make that insane - base running.

To this day, Reds OF Eric Davis is recalled for making a great throw to third to nail the Pirates' Bobby Bonilla, by a foot, in Game 4 of the 1990 NLCS. And that foot, and then some, was the result of Bonilla's failure to initially run hard, apparently thinking he had homered. The ball smacked off the wall and back toward the infield before Davis ran it down.

When Bonilla swung, there was one out in the eighth and the Bucs were down a game and a run. Bonilla should have been on third, one out. Pittsburgh would lose that game, 5-3, and the series in six. And what's regarded among the biggest plays in that series was the byproduct of a big leaguer's conditioned failure to adhere to Little League Rule No. 1: hit ball, run.

Bonilla never got his own message. In the years that followed, he remained disinclined to run after hitting a deep fly, continuing to look TV-highlights slick at the risk of appearing terribly foolish. Manny Ramirez, Rickey Henderson and Mike Piazza all cost their teams plenty, choosing not to run, but that never stopped them from not running.


I thought the columnist was wrong so I was going to email him, but I thought I better ask Redszone first.

[markymark69]

O'Neill threw out Andy Van Slyke in Game Two at Riverfront and Davis gunned down Bonilla at Three Rivers in Game Four after the ball eluded Billy Hatcher in centerfield.

[Doro]

it was definately Davis throwing out Bonilla. I watched Wire to Wire 100,000 times and that was my favorite part.

[dsmith421]

Biggest play of that series (for me) was Glenn Braggs robbing Carmelo Martinez of what would have been a game-tying home run. I can't remember what game it was in, maybe Game 6?

[George Foster]

Biggest play of that series (for me) was Glenn Braggs robbing Carmelo Martinez of what would have been a game-tying home run. I can't remember what game it was in, maybe Game 6?

It was game 6, and it would of been hard to beat them in game 7. That was the biggest play of the series in my opinion

[jfar23]

I've got video of the Eric Davis play throwing out Bonilla at third. I had it on youtube but the mlb cops act fast. Even the call is great. "He is...OUT AT THIRD BASE!"

[George Anderson]

Biggest play of that series (for me) was Glenn Braggs robbing Carmelo Martinez of what would have been a game-tying home run. I can't remember what game it was in, maybe Game 6?

Funny thing is I was in right field and we were not able to see Braggs make the catch because of where we were sitting. I just remember a deep drive to right field by the Pirates player and thinking the game is tied!! Then everyone around us went nuts and we had to figure Braggs made some type of great catch. I cant remember if the Reds had replay on the video screens back then but I do remember I couldnt totally appreciate Braggs catch till I was able to later watch it on TV.

[dsmith421]

I went to probably 30 games that year (skipping at least 8 days of school--sorry Western Row Elementary) and one of the greatest memories of my life was getting off the bus the day of Game 1 of the NLCS to see my dad--who never got off early--waving two box seat tickets at me as I hit the ground.

And if Sabo had got a bunt down we'd have won that game. But you know, I'd give a loss in Game 1 for a World Title any day.

[dsmith421]

Also, and I mean this very seriously, what would it take to get a DVD release of the entire Reds 1990 playoff run? I know Channel 5 had all the games then... I have Game 4 of the Series on tape but that's it.

[dsmith421]

Funny thing is I was in right field and we were not able to see Braggs make the catch because of where we were sitting. I just remember a deep drive to right field by the Pirates player and thinking the game is tied!! Then everyone around us went nuts and we had to figure Braggs made some type of great catch.

After going to Retrosheet I realized that "fly ball" happened in the 9th inning of Game 6. I can't believe that I didn't actually die in front of the television.

And then Myers struck out Slaught and that was that.

Incidentally, that was a really good Pittsburgh team.

[Mutaman]

Ironically, Phil Mushnick's column on Friday in the New York Post featured Eric's throw:

LAME EXCUSES HAVE TO RUN OUT
By PHIL MUSHNICK


June 1, 2007 -- NOTE to Willie Randolph: Pander now, pay later.
Not that I'd pretend to tell Randolph how to manage, I'm just a baseball fan with TiVo. But I'm sure of one essential of baseball that Randolph, at least publicly and through the comportment of his players, doesn't seem convinced is essential: Running to first base.

Running to first can't prevent a team from winning a game, a pennant or a World Series. Not running to first can prevent all three.

Since 1990, when the hideous, cool-over-function trend of jogging toward first or immodestly loitering near home plate in the often erroneous presumption the ball will land over the fence had fully set in, big-league games have been determined by inexcusably indifferent - make that insane - base running.

To this day, Reds OF Eric Davis is recalled for making a great throw to third to nail the Pirates' Bobby Bonilla, by a foot, in Game 4 of the 1990 NLCS. And that foot, and then some, was the result of Bonilla's failure to initially run hard, apparently thinking he had homered. The ball smacked off the wall and back toward the infield before Davis ran it down.

When Bonilla swung, there was one out in the eighth and the Bucs were down a game and a run. Bonilla should have been on third, one out. Pittsburgh would lose that game, 5-3, and the series in six. And what's regarded among the biggest plays in that series was the byproduct of a big leaguer's conditioned failure to adhere to Little League Rule No. 1: hit ball, run.

Bonilla never got his own message. In the years that followed, he remained disinclined to run after hitting a deep fly, continuing to look TV-highlights slick at the risk of appearing terribly foolish. Manny Ramirez, Rickey Henderson and Mike Piazza all cost their teams plenty, choosing not to run, but that never stopped them from not running.

To that end, Carlos Delgado, last Friday, in the seventh inning of a scoreless game, was thrown out at second because he didn't initially run on a shot he hit to left-center that would have cleared the wall if only it hadn't. Embarrassing, counterproductive stuff, doubly so from the acknowledged team leader.

Yet that didn't prevent Delgado, four nights later in a close game, from failing to run to first before each of the two home runs he hit cleared the wall. Of course, he knew both were gone. Of course, he knew the homer he hit Friday was gone, too, the home run he hit when he was thrown out at second.

It appears that given the opportunity to be similarly thrown out tomorrow, next week or this September, Delgado, a slave to the fashion, will choose to do it again. He'd even, again, risk injury with an awkward slide at second, as opposed to reaching second standing up.

Of all the nutty things that have happened to our sports, from uncontested layups eschewed in favor of check-this-out slams that clang off the rim, to football games determined by taunting and showboating penalties, to Olympic skiing gold medals sacrificed to hot-dogging just short of the finish line, nothing seems as nuts as choosing not to run to first base.