Could the Pine Tar incident kill any chances the Reds had at getting Dave Duncan?

[JayBruceFan]

The Reds seem to be hell bent on blowing Duncan out of the water right now and Arroyo is leading the charge.

I think this probably just killed any chance that the Reds had at getting Dave Duncan


Thoughts?

[davereds24]

they never had a shot to begin with, just wishful thinking

[markymark69]

I agree with both sentiments. They had very little chance to land him in the first place and this just cemented it. If you're Arroyo would you want a guy that accused you of cheating, coaching you? Not me.

[cinredsfan2000]

Maybe maybe not depends what the relationship with walt was before he left ? anybody know if there was some sort of rift between them where mngmt. in St.louis