Originally Posted by
Ky Fried Redleg
184. This is the story of one of the most bizarre songs in the history of Billboard charted music. We have to go back more than 55 years for this one. The song in question here was recorded in 1970 by a five-member American pop band that formed in the Wilkes Barre /Scranton PA area back in 1965. They released eight singles during their active run between 1969 and 1975, but it the biggest of those singles that is the subject of this question. In fact, it is the only major hit this band ever had.
The band had signed a single record deal with Scepter Records (same record label as BJ Thomas). But when the label refused to provide the financial assistance to promote the record, the band called on a young 20 year-old singer/songwriter for help. The writer's plan was to let controversy promote the record. He would write a song with an implied subject matter so controversial that the song would be banned, thus generating interest and boosting record sales. We all know that controversy creates interest.
The writer's inspiration came from the country song " Sixteen Tons" and the Tennessee Williams play Suddenly, Last Summer, combining a tragic miner's tale with the taboo topic of cannibalism.
The writer wanted the song to get played on the radio but , at the same time, he wanted the dark, macabre subject matter to get the song banned by radio stations to create buzz. To get past radio censors and drum up buzz, and make the song appealing to listeners, he disguised the borderline-gruesome lyrics to a degree by juxtaposing them against a light, bouncy melody with a heavy emphasis on brass and string orchestrated and conducted by Howard Reeves. Whenever I think of this song , I am reminded of Warren Zevon's "Exciteable Boy," a song with a very dark subject matter of rape and murder of a prom date , but with a light, bouncy, pop melody.
The writer's plan worked to perfection. Radio stations caught on to the dark theme and immediately started banning the track. However, the controversy made teens highly curious, leading to massive record-buying and relentless song requests that forced other stations to play it to keep up with demand . Another thing of note, once Scepter Records realized the song was climbing the charts, they panicked and tried to quiet the outrage by telling DJs that the subject of the song was actually a mule, rather than a human. The writer pushed back , however, confirming the song was indeed about cannibalism.
The young writer and arranger of this song also played piano on the track, just as he did on "Tracy, " the hit song by the Cufflinks in 1969. He also played the signature piano riff on the '76 hit "A Glass of Champagne," by the British rock band , Sailor, and then went on to have his own #1 hit in 1979 and another top 10 hit in 1980.
Do you know the title of this controversial song , which peaked at #17 on the Billboard Hot 100 in the spring of 1971(it was #87 for all of 1971) ? Also, do you know the name of the writer , arranger, and piano player on the record? And , can you name his huge hit, which peaked at #1 in 1979 , and holds the unique distinction of being the only pop song in history to ascend to #1 on Billboard in two different decades(same chart run) ? It was the last #1 song of the 70's.