2019/2020 Prospect Poll, #1

[Kinsm]

Mods need to lock this thread, move voting and discussion to the other one.

[mth123]

Greene's also got the biggest chance of the top guys of never seeing the majors. We're still pretending he's the next Dwight Gooden when he's already not the next Dwight Gooden. Honestly I don't think anyone knows what he's going to be. He's got to recover from his surgery and then learn how to pitch (and build up his innings load from just about zero). I know the exercise here is to rate everyone, but the main thing we know about Greene is we have no idea what or where he's going to be in a year or two. I'm putting Greene off to the side until he's back on the mound and we see what we've got. I still have high hopes for him. Perfectly willing to slot him in at #1 in the future. Just not getting my vote for any slot this year.

I agree with that. I don't think the Reds have a true number 1 prospect. Greene has the most upside. It's not how I usually vote, but I think it's the right answer this year.