Defense is extremely overrated, in that case.
We're talking two to four outs (literally, in the case of this past season) between average and below.
I can live with one or two balls dropping in front of a fielder or missed swipes at a ball in the dirt if the player can OPS in the 850 - 900 range.
Castellanos can do that. Winker too.
No other Cincinnati OF has a prayer of doing it.