Quote Originally Posted by Old school 1983 View Post
You’re ignoring the years of control and the fact that Suarez has been terrible outside of a couple months for the past 2 years. They get 2 years of Winker and 3 years of Suarez. 3-4 years of a steady 4-5 starter is probably 6-9 WAR if you take 2-3 WAR as a good BOR starter. I think that’s about what you can expect out of Winker and Suarez over the life of the deal. Unles Suarez turns back into 2019 Suarez.
We really, really disagree about this.

You're arguing that quantity is better than quality.

Any team worth its salt could find a BOR starter. They're, almost by definition, fungible.

We continue to disagree about your mischaracterization of Winker and of Suarez as players. It's frustrating to try and discuss topics because of those repeated mischaracterizations.