I guess we are on different pages when it comes to Alfredo's speed and defense. I know those factors are harder to quantify so I can see that they would be up for debate a bit more. As for the baserunning, I have never seen him run or seen a clock on him, so I am just going based upon some dated reports and the fact that he already has 8 steals. As for the defense, it's even more based upon reports and the fact that he only has 2 errors in 41 games.